The Forgotten History Of Rabbit Starvation

What you’re getting yourself into

How the hunters and explorers of old knew that lean protein could kill you, and why modern nutrition has fatefully abandoned this wisdom.

Northern Canada, winter of 1906. Arctic explorer Vilhjalmur Stefansson sits in a camp with a group of forest-dwelling Indians, watching them prepare their evening meal after a successful hunt. The men have brought down several rabbits, and Stefansson expects a feast. Instead, he watches with growing confusion as the hunters methodically strip the lean meat from the carcasses and toss it to their dogs, who devour it eagerly. The men keep only the small deposits of kidney fat and whatever meager back fat they can scrape together, mixing it carefully with dried meat they’d stored from previous hunts of moose and beaver.

“Why waste perfectly good meat?” Stefansson asks. The answer, delivered with the casual certainty of generations of survival wisdom, stops him cold: “Rabbit makes you weak. You can eat until your belly hurts, but you’ll starve anyway.”

This wasn’t superstition. It was hard-won knowledge about a metabolic reality that could kill you in a matter of weeks. The Indians called it “rabbit starvation.” The French-Canadian trappers knew it as “mal de caribou.” Modern science would eventually classify it as protein poisoning. But whatever the name, the phenomenon was the same: despite consuming seemingly adequate amounts of food, men wasted away, developed unshakeable diarrhea, suffered splitting headaches, and eventually died with full stomachs and empty fuel tanks.

The traditional knowledge was clear and universal across cultures that depended on hunting: fat was the prize, not protein. The lean meat? That was for the dogs.

When Roman Legions Met Rabbit

The earliest documented case of protein poisoning dates to 150 BC, during Rome’s conquest of Spain. The Roman legions, those disciplined warriors who’d conquered most of the known world on a diet rich in fatty meat, wine, olive oil, and salt, found themselves in dire straits when supply lines broke down. The Spanish countryside offered abundant game, particularly rabbits, and the soldiers gorged themselves on the lean meat mixed with meager rations of bulgur and barley.

Within days, severe diarrhea swept through the ranks. Men ate until their stomachs distended, yet complained of constant hunger and profound weakness. Many died, not from starvation in the conventional sense, but from a surfeit of the wrong kind of food. Their bodies, drowning in protein but starved of fat and adequate carbohydrate, simply couldn’t generate enough energy to sustain life.

The Roman commanders, accustomed to military precision, watched helplessly as discipline dissolved into chaos. Soldiers became irritable, lethargic, and mentally foggy. The headaches were relentless. No amount of rabbit flesh seemed to satisfy. They were experiencing what their descendants would call “fat-hunger”, a gnawing, insatiable craving that no amount of lean meat could touch.

Arctic Expeditions and the Greely Disaster

Fast forward to 1881, when Lieutenant Adolphus Greely led an American expedition to the Arctic. Of the 25 men who set out, only six would return alive. While multiple factors contributed to the catastrophe, protein poisoning played a devastating role.

Stefansson, who later studied the Greely expedition extensively, identified “rabbit starvation” as the key to understanding why so many died. The survivors had likely resorted to cannibalism, but here’s the crucial detail: they were cannibalising the lean flesh of companions who’d already died. Human muscle tissue is exceptionally lean, particularly on bodies already ravaged by starvation. The survivors were essentially eating rabbit-equivalent meat, consuming massive amounts of protein that their livers couldn’t process while generating toxic levels of ammonia and urea.

Those who died first, Stefansson argued, were likely those who ate the most lean meat in a desperate attempt to stave off hunger. They literally ate themselves to death.

Stefansson’s Own Brush With Death

Stefansson himself nearly became a casualty of protein poisoning. After spending years thriving on the high-fat Inuit diet of seal blubber and fatty fish, he found himself traveling with a group of Native Americans who were forced to subsist primarily on caribou during a lean season. But this wasn’t the fat-rich caribou of autumn. This was spring caribou, animals that had burned through their fat reserves during the harsh winter, leaving nothing but lean, stringy muscle.

Stefansson’s own account is chilling in its clinical precision. Within days, the entire party developed diarrhea. Headaches became constant companions. A pervasive lassitude settled over everyone, sapping the will to move despite adequate caloric intake on paper. Most disturbingly, no matter how much they ate, the gnawing hunger never abated. Their stomachs were distended from gorging on lean meat, yet their bodies screamed for sustenance.

“We could eat until our stomachs were distended,” Stefansson wrote, “but no matter how much we ate, we felt unsatisfied.” The group tore through their 60-day supply of meat in under a month, driven by a ravenous hunger that no amount of protein could touch.

Relief came from an unexpected source: a single teacup of oil. That small serving of concentrated fat, passed around the desperate group, produced almost immediate improvement. The fog lifted. The energy returned. The hunger, finally, began to recede. It wasn’t more protein they needed. It was fat.

Canadian explorer and author Farley Mowat experienced the same phenomenon while living among the Ilhalmiut people. When protein poisoning struck, his guide cured him by having him drink lard. Not broth enriched with lard. Just straight lard.

The Dogs Knew Better

The Inuit and northern forest Indians had observed this phenomenon for millennia. Their solution was elegant in its simplicity: reserve the lean meat for the dogs, keep the fat for the humans.

When hunters brought down game, the butchering followed strict protocols honed over thousands of years. They preferentially hunted older animals because mature caribou, moose, and elk had built up substantial fat reserves. A thousand-pound caribou could carry 40 to 50 pounds of back fat alone, with another 20 to 30 pounds of highly saturated cavity fat. This precious fat was carefully rendered, stored in bladders or intestines, and consumed alongside dried or smoked lean meat.

The ratio was telling: fat contributed nearly 80% of total calories in the diets of northern Indians. The protein was there, certainly, but it played a supporting role to the main event.

Small game like rabbit and squirrel were eaten only when nothing else was available, and even then, preparation required special attention. The lean meat had to be carefully balanced with whatever fat sources could be scrounged, beaver tail, fish oil, or rendered fat from previous kills. Eating rabbit or squirrel straight, without additional fat, was considered a form of slow suicide.

The dogs, meanwhile, thrived on the lean scraps their human companions rejected. Their metabolism could handle higher protein loads. The humans, blessed with larger brains and more complex metabolic demands, required the caloric density that only fat could provide.

The Biochemistry of Protein Poisoning

The traditional wisdom wasn’t mysticism. It was metabolic reality, and the science explains exactly why lean meat becomes poison.

The human liver can metabolize approximately 285 to 365 grams of protein per day, roughly 2 grams per kilogram of body weight. Beyond this threshold, the metabolic machinery starts to buckle. The kidneys have a limited capacity to eliminate the waste products of protein metabolism, urea, uric acid, and particularly ammonia.

Here’s where it gets ugly. When your body is forced to derive energy primarily from protein in the absence of adequate fat or carbohydrate, every gram of protein must be broken down through a process called gluconeogenesis, converting amino acids into glucose for fuel. This process strips off the amino groups, generating toxic ammonia as a byproduct.

Ammonia is profoundly toxic, particularly to the central nervous system. Even slightly elevated blood ammonia levels cause the symptoms Stefansson described: headaches, mental fog, irritability, and that gnawing sense of malaise. The liver frantically converts ammonia to urea through the urea cycle, but this process is energy-intensive and has hard limits. When you’re eating 500 grams of protein daily to meet a 2,000-calorie requirement, you’re generating far more ammonia than your liver and kidneys can safely process.

The result? Hyperammonemia. Your blood becomes toxic with metabolic waste. Ammonia crosses the blood-brain barrier where astrocytes metabolize it into glutamine, increasing osmotic pressure and causing cerebral edema, brain swelling. The classic signs appear: confusion, vomiting, slurred speech, and that characteristic “liver flap” tremor called asterixis.

Meanwhile, the excessive protein metabolism taxes both liver and kidneys to their breaking point. The diarrhea that plagued those Roman soldiers and Arctic explorers? That’s your gastrointestinal tract rebelling against the metabolic chaos. The profound weakness? That’s your cells starving for usable energy while drowning in protein.

Fat and carbohydrate don’t generate these toxic byproducts. They burn cleanly, providing energy without overwhelming your detoxification systems. This is why that teacup of oil saved Stefansson’s life. It provided concentrated calories that his body could actually use, taking pressure off the overwhelmed protein-processing machinery.

The Traditional Wisdom: Fat Was the Prize

Every successful hunting culture understood this intuitively. The Inuit, living in one of the harshest environments on Earth, valued seal blubber and whale fat above all other foods. They ate the lean meat, certainly, but it was always accompanied by generous portions of fat. Often they’d eat pure animal fat in addition to fatty meats. When food was scarce, they’d feed the lean portions to their dogs and keep the fat for themselves.

Stefansson noted that northern Indians hunting caribou specifically targeted older males, waiting for autumn when the animals had fattened up. They would sometimes abandon kills if the animals were too lean, a decision that baffled European observers who couldn’t fathom “wasting” meat. But the hunters knew: lean meat without fat wasn’t food. It was a liability.

Pemmican, the legendary survival food of Native Americans, reflected this wisdom perfectly. The formula was simple: equal parts rendered fat and powdered dried meat, sometimes enhanced with berries. The 1:1 ratio wasn’t arbitrary. It was the proportion that provided complete nutrition and prevented protein poisoning. Five pounds of fresh meat produced one pound of dried meat, which was then mixed with an equal weight of fat.

When prepared correctly, pemmican could sustain a person indefinitely. British explorer Robert Falcon Scott wrote that the Hudson Bay Company had records of trappers dying of starvation while living on an easily available diet of rabbit. They’d eaten well, by volume. They’d simply eaten the wrong thing.

The Modern Madness: Chicken Breast and Egg Whites

Fast forward to 2025, and we’ve managed to completely invert millennia of survival wisdom. Walk into any supermarket, flip through any fitness magazine, scan any diet blog, and you’ll be bombarded with the same message: lean protein is king. Chicken breast is virtuous. Egg whites are pure. Full-fat dairy is dangerous. Fat makes you fat.

This is, and there’s no gentle way to put this, catastrophically wrong.

The modern obesity epidemic didn’t emerge from people eating too much ribeye and butter. It coincided precisely with the low-fat dietary guidelines that demonized saturated fat and promoted lean protein with plenty of “healthy whole grains.” We replaced traditional animal fats with industrial seed oils, traded fatty cuts for skinless chicken breast, and convinced ourselves that egg whites were superior to whole eggs.

The bodybuilding community took this to extremes that would make Arctic explorers weep. Meal prep containers filled with dry chicken breast and plain rice. Egg white omelets. Protein shakes mixed with water. Zero-fat Greek yogurt. The goal? Maximize protein, minimize fat, get shredded.

What actually happens? The same metabolic stress that killed those Roman soldiers, just spread out over months and years instead of weeks. You won’t die of protein poisoning from eating chicken breast and broccoli. Your liver won’t fail from a diet of egg whites and oatmeal. But you will suppress your metabolism in ways that echo the acute crisis of rabbit starvation.

The Consequences: Metabolic Suppression

High-protein, low-fat diets dramatically suppress thyroid hormone activity, particularly the conversion of T4 to the active T3 form. One study found that T3 levels declined significantly on a high-protein diet where fat was replaced with additional protein. The more extreme the protein-to-fat ratio, the worse the suppression.

Why does this matter? Thyroid hormones regulate your basal metabolic rate, the energy you burn just existing. Suppressed T3 means suppressed metabolism. You feel cold. You’re perpetually tired. Your brain feels foggy. You’re irritable and anxious. Your hair thins. Your skin dries out. Sound familiar? Those are the exact symptoms early-stage protein poisoning produces, just stretched across a longer timeline.

Low-protein diets cause thyroid suppression too, but the sweet spot appears to be moderate protein with generous fat. The ratio our ancestors intuitively maintained: 20% protein, 80% fat and carbohydrate combined, with the bulk of calories coming from fat.

The fitness industry’s obsession with high protein creates a different problem: chronic metabolic stress. Your liver is working overtime to process excess protein. Your kidneys are straining to eliminate waste products. Your thyroid is downregulating to conserve energy. You’re in a perpetual low-grade version of the metabolic chaos that killed Arctic explorers.

The Energy Crisis

The cruel irony of lean protein obsession is that it creates the exact problem it’s meant to solve: insufficient energy. Your body requires either fat or carbohydrate for efficient energy production. Protein can be converted to glucose through gluconeogenesis, but this process is metabolically expensive, produces toxic byproducts, and was never meant to be your primary fuel source.

When you restrict both fat and carbohydrate while loading up on protein, your body enters a twilight zone between fuel sources. You’re not in ketosis, which would provide efficient energy from fat. You’re not fueled by glucose from carbohydrates. You’re forcing your liver to convert protein to glucose while generating ammonia and urea at rates your body struggles to handle.

The result? That peculiar state of feeling full but starved. Exhausted despite adequate calories. Hungry despite eating massive volumes of food. It’s rabbit starvation in slow motion.

The Fat Redemption

The solution isn’t complicated. It’s the same wisdom those northern Indians practiced: respect the fat.

This doesn’t mean gorging on bacon until you achieve cardiovascular disease. It means understanding that dietary fat, particularly saturated fat from animal sources, isn’t the villain it’s been painted as. It means recognizing that skinless chicken breast isn’t superior to chicken thighs. That whole eggs are nutritionally superior to egg whites in every measurable way. That full-fat dairy provides nutrients and satiety that skim milk can’t touch.

Traditional diets that sustained healthy populations included generous amounts of animal fat: tallow, lard, butter, cream, fatty fish, marbled meat. These weren’t guilty pleasures. They were nutritional staples that provided energy, fat-soluble vitamins, and the feeling of genuine satiety that protein alone can never deliver.

When Stefansson returned to New York in 1928, he participated in a famous experiment. For an entire year, he and a colleague ate nothing but meat and water while under medical supervision at Bellevue Hospital. Critics predicted disaster, organ failure, scurvy, some spectacular medical catastrophe.

Instead? Perfect health. The secret? About 80% of their calories came from fat, with only 20% from protein. They were eating nose-to-tail, including organs and plenty of fat with every meal. They thrived.

The moment they tried eating lean meat exclusively, even for a few days? The symptoms returned. Weakness. Diarrhea. That gnawing hunger. They course-corrected immediately, returning to fatty cuts and organ meats.

The Practical Takeaway

You won’t die from eating too many chicken breasts. Modern life doesn’t present the extreme scenarios that killed Roman soldiers or nearly claimed Stefansson’s life. But you might be suppressing your metabolism, creating unnecessary stress on your liver and kidneys, and making weight management far harder than it needs to be.

The ancestral wisdom was simple: protein is structural, fat is fuel. You need adequate protein for tissue repair and immune function, roughly 0.8 to 1.2 grams per kilogram of body weight for most people. Beyond that, additional protein provides diminishing returns and creates metabolic costs.

Fat, meanwhile, provides concentrated energy without toxic byproducts. It enables absorption of fat-soluble vitamins. It provides satiety. It supports hormone production. It doesn’t spike blood sugar. It doesn’t stress your liver the way excess protein does.

Choose fattier cuts of meat. Keep the skin on your chicken. Eat whole eggs. Use butter, tallow, and lard without guilt. Stop treating fat like poison and lean protein like virtue. Your metabolism will thank you.

The Dogs Still Know

Those northern Indians who threw lean meat to their dogs while keeping the fat for themselves weren’t being wasteful or superstitious. They were following metabolic wisdom encoded in thousands of years of survival.

The dogs thrived on lean meat because their shorter digestive tracts and different metabolic demands made it work. Humans, with our energy-hungry brains and complex metabolic requirements, need the caloric density that only fat provides.

We’ve spent the past 50 years trying to outsmart this evolutionary reality with low-fat dogma and lean protein worship. The results speak for themselves: epidemic obesity, metabolic syndrome, thyroid disorders, chronic fatigue, and a population that’s simultaneously overfed and undernourished.

Perhaps it’s time to stop feeding ourselves like dogs and start eating like the apex predator we are. That means respecting fat as the evolutionary fuel source it’s always been, not treating it as the enemy.

The Romans learned this lesson the hard way in Spain. Arctic explorers learned it the hard way in the frozen north. Indigenous peoples learned it over millennia of trial and error.

How many more chicken breasts do we need to choke down before we remember what our ancestors knew: protein without fat isn’t food. It’s a liability our bodies can barely process.

The lean meat? That’s still for the dogs. The fat? That’s for the humans who want to thrive instead of merely surviving on metabolic life support.

Read My Previous Article – The Forgotten History Of Carnivore Nutrition

If you want to figure out the best way to set up your own metabolic revival, reach out to me on Twitter, Instagram, or sign up to my coaching programme below for customised hypertrophy programmes and carnivore nutrition plans that will ditch all the unnecessary fluff and send you hurtling towards your physique goals.